At CloudFest Americas in Miami, both sides of one hosting deal shared a stage. On November 12, Michele Neylon, who co-founded the Irish registrar and host Blacknight in 2003 and still runs it, and Henk Mosterd, head of sourcing for Your.Online in North America, talked through Blacknight’s sale to the group. The session was moderated by our co-founder Konrad Keck.

Blacknight announced in June that it was joining Your.Online. The panel, titled “The Great Growth Debate: Buy, Build, or Both?”, looked at the deal from three angles: why a founder sells, what a buyer looks for beyond the numbers, and what changes once the company has a new owner.

The Decision to Sell

The conversation opened with the decision itself and the emotions that came before it. Konrad asked whether the sale was driven by changes in the market, the demands of running an independent company, or financial considerations. Timing came up as well: what finally tipped the balance after more than two decades as a standalone business.

In its June announcements, Blacknight pointed to access to a wider network of expertise, resources and investment, and Neylon described the step as “strengthening the foundations for the future.”

What the Buyer Looks For

On Your.Online’s side, the topic was what the group values in a company beyond its financial results, including the role of founders and leadership. Its website describes a decentralized model, in which entrepreneurs stay in control of their operations, brand, team, culture and values.

Mosterd represents Your.Online in North America, where Pittsburgh-based Pair Networks was the group’s first step into the US market and this year’s acquisition of UK2 Group strengthened its US presence. The panel looked at how the region differs from Europe in valuations, acquisitions and the deal process, and at whether valuations in the industry have changed recently.

Life After the Sale

Another part of the conversation focused on Neylon’s position after the deal: what it is like to sell the company and continue to lead it, how the role has changed, and whether the goals and the motivation behind them have shifted.

The discussion also touched on Your.Online’s long-term aims. The group, which traces its roots to 2017, has completed more than 60 acquisitions, and its brands serve over 1.3 million customers. It describes a “buy and hold forever” strategy built on growth through acquisitions and faster expansion within the companies that join.

Get one-on-one advice on maximizing your hosting company’s valuation and navigating the sale process.

Final Thoughts

The panel brought together two perspectives on one transaction. For Your.Online, Blacknight is part of a group built through more than 60 acquisitions. For Neylon, it is the company he co-founded in 2003, now under new ownership but still led by him.